"There are no two words in the English language more harmful than
good job.”
good job.”
Whiplash was a film that I had heard nothing but Oscar buzz and high praises for so, needless to say, I was excited to finally get to see it.
A young jazz drummer with a lot of potential is accepted into a respected music conservatory where he gets the opportunity to be mentored by a cut-throat instructor who will stop at nothing to push his students.
I was feeling an unusual combination of thrilled and somewhat let down coming out of ‘Whiplash’…
First and foremost, J.K. Simmons definitely deserves the Oscar for his supporting performance as the absolutely terrifying Terence Fletcher. There’s a lot of tension in the film but it’s not a ghost lurking down a dark hallway waiting to give you a scare, instead, it comes in the form of J.K. Simmons. There's not one second of the entire time he’s on (and off) screen that you don’t feel his presence. I feel like this is the role that he was born to play. He is brutal, witty and powerful.
I believe that everyone, at one point in their life, will encounter a person like Terence Fletcher. I know I have.
When he is pushing the young drummer Andrew to his limits, you genuinely believe that there’s nothing he won’t do to get the results he’s looking for... Including some more unethical approaches that throw up some interesting questions.
You see both his professional side and his personal life and he manages to balance them perfectly in the character. Which is the act? Is he just pushing his students because it's his job or is he putting on the "nice guy" act when he's outside of the rehearsal room? Who is the real Terence Fletcher? It makes for a very intriguing character.
What I really enjoyed seeing was the band situation where Terence Fletcher takes control. I have been sitting on one of those chairs with a conductor that won’t hesitate to single you out in front of the entire band or even throw you out. It was thrilling to watch because I could really relate to it.
It is tense and you can’t help but cling on to the edge of your seat, wondering what Fletcher will do next. Anyone who has been in a large band will understand the pressures of the situation but Director Damien Chazelle does a great job in highlighting it anyway.
I was extremely disappointed in Miles Teller’s performance as Andrew.
I was hoping for either a great actor trying to mime the drums or a great drummer trying to act well. However, what we get with Teller is a mediocre actor miming the drums badly… Which is so heartbreaking when he is being outshone by his counterpart J.K. Simmons, I’d have loved to have seen two fantastic actors going head to head but you never feel like Teller pulls it off. This might be down to experience but it really shows when they are at each others throats.
His drumming is totally off the mark.
The timing is way off and it’s a struggle to really believe him as a player. It seems like he’s had some basic teaching for the role but I can't help but feel like he should be more than competent for the complex parts that he’s meant to be playing. Maybe I’m just being over-critical because I’m a musician but there was a lot of fast cutting and canted angles to cover his sticks which was either a stylistic choice or purely to cover his lack of ability on the drums. I sense it might be a mixture of both. This was extremely frustrating to watch as it took me out of the movie instantly, I don’t mind miming in movies but it has to be done perfectly to make it invisible.
When it came to his performance off the kit, I always felt that he was just “acting” the whole time. It was forced and there was never a natural flow to his performance that I could sink in to and enjoy. Possibly this is because J.K. Simmons totally embodies his character in every detail, it highlights the other actors who don’t seem as comfortable in their roles.
One of the biggest questions in the film is "Is it worth it?".
What's the point in being the best if you have nothing else to show for it?
If you end up hating your talent, is it worth doing? It promotes the idea that you have to be the most skilled player to be the best but I felt the opposite while watching ‘Whiplash’. I felt that the performances and the music were all skill and no heart. It was shallow despite being technically perfect. There was never any feeling in the music that I thought I’d appreciate in the film, it came from the characters around the instruments but never from the music itself. It became more about hitting every note rather than what the music was about. In that sense there was a slight hint of elitism in the film. You can be the best player on the planet but if there's no emotion or love for it then what's the point?
The stakes are always high in ‘Whiplash’ and they are always raised. Each act just cranks the tension up and tightens the grip around your throat. It was well paced as each scene seems to be larger and more hardcore than the last.
It was really fun to watch the constant manipulation from Fletcher and how he takes it to the next level, he keeps abusing his authority and eventually using other students to get Andrew to where he needs to be. He'll be kicking and screaming the whole way but, because of how badly Andrew wants to succeed and impress Fletcher, he'll go along with it.
It was really fun to watch the constant manipulation from Fletcher and how he takes it to the next level, he keeps abusing his authority and eventually using other students to get Andrew to where he needs to be. He'll be kicking and screaming the whole way but, because of how badly Andrew wants to succeed and impress Fletcher, he'll go along with it.
When it comes to performing the pieces in the film it’s not just about playing them well, it becomes about playing them flawlessly. Fletcher is such a perfectionist that he demands the absolute best from each and every player in the band and is willing to mentally and physically abuse them to get the best. This raises a very interesting subject in the realm of teaching and leading. What is the right way? Is there a right way?
It seems extreme in the film but, at the end of the day, Fletcher gets the results. Did he go about it in the right way? Absolutely not but he did get the best out of Andrew’s skill. Abusing the people you are meant to be teaching/leading isn’t what I would consider the “right way” of doing things, I don’t think it is the “right way” of doing things in any walk of life. I personally believe that that form of teaching/leading almost never works but it makes a compelling case for it in ‘Whiplash’.
Overall, Whiplash was exciting with an unforgettable performance from J.K. Simmons but a slightly uneven and unbelievable performance from Miles Teller. It challenges the audience to think but does feel slightly pretentious (sorry Oscar guys)… Worth a watch nonetheless.